Every December, Education Next releases a list of the most popular articles we published over the course of the year based on readership.
This year, the most popular article by far sought to provide evidence-based advice to parents who may be wondering if they should delay their child’s entry into kindergarten for a year, a practice known as academic redshirting.
The list includes some good news for education reformers, including an examination of how one state is already seeing positive results from its decision to put a high-quality curriculum at the heart of its reform efforts; a look at how the hottest show on Broadway is inspiring a generation of students to explore American history; and a deep dive into the world of higher education with an array of new experiments that are making college degrees more accessible, especially for at-risk students.
There are also articles about obstacles to greater progress: a study reveals that teacher expectations impact students’ likelihood of completing college and are often lower for black students than for their white counterparts, even after accounting for students’ academic and demographic backgrounds; and a look at how allowing laptop use in the classroom actually distracts from student learning.
Here’s the list of 2017’s Top Twenty Articles:
|1.||Is Your Child Ready for Kindergarten?
Redshirting may do more harm than good
By Diane Whitmore Schanzenbach and Stephanie Howard Larson
|2.||Louisiana Threads the Needle on Ed Reform
Launching a coherent curriculum in a local-control state
By Robert Pondiscio
|3.||Betsy DeVos, the (Relatively Mainstream) Reformer
A long record refutes the radical image of the education secretary
By Michael Q. McShane
|4.||The 2017 EdNext Poll on School Reform
Public thinking on school choice, Common Core, higher ed, and more
By Martin R. West, Michael B. Henderson, Paul E. Peterson and Samuel Barrows
|5.||Competency-Based Education, Put to the Test
An inside look at learning and assessment at Western Governors University
By Jon Marcus
|6.||Should Professors Ban Laptops?
How classroom computer use affects student learning
By Susan Payne Carter, Kyle Greenberg and Michael S. Walker
|7.||The Power of Teacher Expectations
How racial bias hinders student attainment
By Seth Gershenson and Nicholas Papageorge
|8.||Will the XQ “Super Schools” Live Up to Their Name?
A new philanthropy’s competition to reinvent high school
By Alexander Russo
|9.||Hamilton Goes to High School
How students are learning U.S. history from the hottest show on Broadway
By Wayne D’Orio
|10.||A Common Core Curriculum Quandary
For Eureka Math, open-source leads to a revenue stream
By Michael J. Petrilli
|11.||The Teacher Evaluation Revamp, In Hindsight
What the Obama administration’s signature reform got wrong
By Chad Aldeman
|12.||Competency-Based Learning for Teachers
Can micro-credentials reboot professional development?
By Michael B. Horn and Thomas Arnett
|13.||Pacesetter in Personalized Learning
Summit charter network shares its model nationwide
By Joanne Jacobs
|14.||Making Evidence Locally
Rethinking education research under the Every Student Succeeds Act
By Thomas J. Kane
Assessing instructor effectiveness in higher education
By Pieter De Vlieger, Brian A. Jacob and Kevin Stange
|16.||Why Most Teachers Get a Bad Deal on Pensions
State plans create more losers than winners, and many get nothing at all
By Chad Aldeman and Kelly Robson
|17.||What Do Parents Think of Their Children’s Schools?
EdNext poll compares charter, district, and private schools nationwide
By Samuel Barrows, Paul E. Peterson and Martin R. West
|18.||A Lasting Impact
High-stakes teacher evaluations drive student success in Washington, D.C
By Thomas S. Dee and James Wyckoff
College students mainstreamed into statistics are more likely to succeed
By Alexandra W. Logue, Mari Watanabe-Rose and Daniel Douglas
|20.||Is Test-Based Accountability Dead?
Three experts weigh in, and look to the future
By Morgan S. Polikoff, Jay P. Greene and Kevin Huffman
Congratulations to all of our authors!
— Education Next
P.P.S. You can find the Top 10 Education Next blog entries of 2017 here.