
I was invited back to the popular education podcast “(Dis)course or ‘Dat Course” to discuss the new season of Emily Hanford’s wildly-successful Sold a Story, which defends direct instruction. Joining me again was S. Smug Snidely, celebrity dean of Paymore U’s school of education; a new guest, Ignatius Cinqful from the National Council for Math Liberation; and host Ima Fuller-Schlitz, author of Love, Hate, Relate: The Case for Schools That Put Feelings First. Here’s the transcript of our illuminating conversation.
Ima Fuller-Schlitz: Welcome, everyone. Today, we’re digging into the second season of Emily Hanford’s Sold a Story, which explores a novel approach to teaching called “direct instruction.” Now I know many teachers have never heard the term, but don’t worry—we’ll catch you up. First, Dr. Snidely, as one of the nation’s leading education authorities, tell us who Emily Hanford is.
Dr. Smug Snidely: She’s an accomplished journalist who works in public radio. That’s what’s so puzzling about her support for dubious education schemes. She did it once with the so-called “science of reading,” and she’s at it again with this ill-fated plunge into the polluted waters of direct instruction.
Fuller-Schlitz: And what exactly is direct instruction?
Snidely: Ima, as I note in my book Pay, Meme, Cognicize, direct instruction—or “DI” as it’s sometimes called—is the nadir of hierarchical schooling. It’s an old, long-discarded industrial model that considers students as products and teachers as replaceable parts, far more suitable for building cars than educating children. Right-wing activists like it because they want to make sure learning itself is conceived as a fundamentally passive process.
Fuller-Schlitz: Here is a good place to bring in Rick Hess of the right-wing think tank world. Dr. Hess, why are right-wingers so enamored of this approach?
Dr. Rick Hess: First, let’s be clear that Emily Hanford is no right-winger. Second, direct instruction is mostly a matter of teachers clearly explaining new concepts, modeling skills, and then guiding students through applied practice. It helps ensure, for instance—
Snidely: Just how much of this MAGA nonsense do you expect us to listen to, sir? As one savvy colleague has observed of DI: “It’s like they’ve taken 1984 and read it as a how-to manual as opposed to a satire.” You can peddle your fascist pedagogies all you like, but the result is long rows of students harangued by power-mad, bow-tied impresarios.
Hess: Bow-tied?
Fuller-Schlitz: What does direct instruction look like in a classroom?
Snidely: It’s not a pretty picture, Ima. Teachers read from prepared scripts, drilling children on the basics of each subject in a highly controlled, even militaristic fashion, offering reinforcement for correct responses as if they were training pets.
Fuller-Schlitz: Like parrots, perhaps?
Hess: Whoa! Let’s talk about the body of evidence showing that direct instruction works, that—
Ignatius Cinqful: Excuse me! If I could speak for just one moment!!
Fuller-Schlitz: Yes, Mr. Cinqful. Your crusade against oppressive pedagogical practices brings such a vital perspective to this conversation. Go ahead.
Cinqful: Dr. Snidely is entirely correct: Direct instruction isn’t about learning at all. It’s a pedagogy of poverty that’s about social control. Direct instruction has become today’s federally-sanctioned child abuse for poor children, designed by those who fear minorities and the poor—bigots typically become obsessed with the need for control.
Fuller-Schlitz: Dr. Snidely, given this compelling evidence, why has direct instruction gained so much momentum?
Snidely: A core text in teacher preparation at Paymore and many schools of education puts it well: “The pedagogy of poverty appeals to . . . those who rely on common sense rather than on thoughtful analysis” because “it is easy to criticize humane and developmental teaching . . . as mere ‘permissiveness’.” DI appeals to those who fear free-thinkers.
Cinqful: Yes! Down with common sense!
Fuller-Schlitz: This is insightful.
Hess: This is insane.
Snidely: And I’ll just remind everyone that, in 2023, Ms. Hanford accepted an award from the neocolonial warmongers at the George W. Bush Presidential Center for helping to promote right-wing, anti-teacher “science of reading” laws.
Cinqful: No Medal Left Behind, am I right?
Hess: Can I point out that there is a sensible middle course here, one that we’ve so far ignored today? DI can be a powerful tool for building foundational knowledge and skills, but it does have limits. Sometimes kids need to be told things, and sometimes they should have room to explore. It’s not either-or.
Cinqful: Well, I don’t compromise with fascists.
Hess: I’ll try again. Look, I see value in DI because I think it vital that every student be able to compute, grasp probabilities, and navigate fractions. Do you really have an issue with that?
Snidely: You are just fixated on forcing youngsters to bow down and worship your tedious bits of rote math, aren’t you? While you may be unaware, there are far more urgent questions than whether six times nine is 67. Questions like, does math instruction promote social justice? Does it tackle structural inequities, climate change, or police misconduct? That, my MAGA mouthpiece, is what I deem crucial.
Cinqful: DI is a pedagogy that turns teachers into machinists and students into products. Look, we don’t become teachers because we’ve decided, “I want to be able to tell people what to do all day and then make them do it!”
Hess: First, that’s a bizarre caricature of DI. Second, teachers are hired to do a job. Sometimes that means telling students what to do and seeing that they do it. What’s the issue?
Fuller-Schlitz: Dr. Hess, I truly am curious why those like you and Emily Hanford embrace a pedagogy that, to build on Mr. Cinqful’s masterful metaphor, turns schools into factories.
Hess: Look, math achievement is dismal. Our students are struggling. What Hanford explores in Sold a Story are ways we can turn that around. Clear direction, repetition, and feedback help students build fluency in foundational skills. Fluency is crucial because—
Cinqful: There, you see?! “Fluency!” You all heard him!! This is all about penalizing kids who aren’t native English-speakers. It’s a feeble guise for anti-immigrant policies.
Hess: Umm, no, I’m talking about fluency in math skills. You see—
Cinqful: Don’t try to MAGAsplain your nonsense to me!
Subscribe to Old School with Rick Hess
Get the latest from Rick, delivered straight to your inbox.
Snidely: Ima, if I may interject. We have to ask ourselves whether the efficient pursuit of improved performance on tests is actually what we want for our children, particularly those who already experience barriers to success due to classism, racism, and white flight. It’s the casual ableism that’s so objectionable. You hear this desperate fascination with labeling children—as “not fluent” or “not proficient”—so that they can be tracked and crammed into boxes by the capitalist regime.
Hess: Wait, now—
Fuller-Schlitz: That’s a profoundly troubling observation, Dr. Snidely. If schools do reject DI, where might they turn? Mr. Cinqful, I believe you are doing work in pedagogy that centers belonging and equity. How do you go about it?
Cinqful: It begins with reenvisioning classroom practices and teachers’ transformative agency. Schools must reject oppressive practices in favor of collaborative vectors and flexible pathways. That’s why we at NCML are committed to circle-based instruction. Reshaping our classrooms into circles communicates equality of voice and membership in the community. Circle gatherings, another indigenous concept, represent the village coming together for dialogue and signal to the learner: “You belong here, just as everyone around you belongs here.”
Snidely: Precisely. And at Paymore, my faculty are quite taken with the “Gesturing Towards Decolonial Futures” collective. It rejects Western modernity in favor of a “collective capacity to re-imagine/re-create existence.” We’ve launched a critical deconstruction of colonial math and are re-centering our teacher training around existence-based pedagogy.
Fuller-Schlitz: Heroic work with moral clarity. And we are clearly out of time. Thank you to our guests and thank you for joining “(Dis)course or ‘Dat Course.” You know me, Ima Fuller Schlitz.
Frederick Hess is an executive editor of Education Next and the author of the blog “Old School with Rick Hess.”


